[EVA] Eva Manga Stage 72
M
bochan at r4.dion.ne.jp
Tue Jul 4 20:53:15 EDT 2006
> But, it can't be interpreted like:
>
> IF the nigouki did not have a soul I COULD join PHYSICALLY with it...
> Now I can control it, BECAUSE we both are born from Adam and the
> Nigouki's soul has sealed away... BUT it has YET a soul, so our
> merging CANNOT be complete (physically), only this lesser grade.
That would require a slight rearrangement of the grammar (see
previous post) and also some additional, unstated information ("now I
can control it" (obviously true but not stated), "lesser grade of
merging" (false IMO)). However, the grammar is what it is, and a
"lesser grade of merging" is like "a little pregnant". You either
are pregnant or not; there either is merging or not. Control is not
merging, and it is possible to control without merging. If Gainax/
Sadamoto had just meant control, then there is any number of words
they could have used instead of "douka (join/merge)".
Of course I also believe that [ability to join/merge if Eva-02 did
not have a soul] can be extrapolated from Kaworu's words, but in this
case that is not what the specific Japanese says.
"M"
More information about the evangelion
mailing list