[EVA] Eva Manga Stage 72

M bochan at r4.dion.ne.jp
Wed Jun 28 21:46:55 EDT 2006


>> Then again, later in this stage there is a monitor image that  
>> shows  Eva-02 and the *17th* Angel breaking through the  
>> partitions.  :P
>
> Ouch. ^^;;
> Though I guess typos are frequent, in manga.

Not really, since they are checked closely before publication.  I am  
sure that Ace-A and Kadokawa are getting a bunch of e-mails and  
letters right about now.


>> Doesn't make sense, does it?
>
> Seeing your other post, it doesn't. It also doesn't look like a  
> sequence that could be broken into parts to make it a "if there  
> wasn't a soul, joining would be possible" followed by "the soul in  
> this unit has shut itself away [thus it is possible to join]".

Yep.

The phrase "the soul of Eva-02 has shut itself away" can be restated  
as "Eva-02 has a soul that has shut itself away," or "Eva-02 has a  
soul".

So, in the first part if Kaworu says "If Eva-02 did not have a soul,"  
this makes the logical relationship:

If not A, then B, because A.
      (A = Eva-02 having a soul)
      (B = ability to join/merge)

Which cannot work.

Ergo, Kaworu must be taking about himself when he says "If XXX did  
not have a soul."

"M"


More information about the evangelion mailing list