[EVA] Lance = S^2 Proof (L=S^2P) [Expanded/New]
bochan at fuji.ne.jp
Sun Apr 9 02:53:28 EDT 2000
>>By the same logic:
>>The Angels came from Adam. If they have S^2s, then ipso facto their
>>S^2s must be Adam's.
>>True? No. Flimsy logic.
No. Flimsy example.
The Angels were born from Adam. They are his "descendants".
The Lance was taken from Adam (donor/provider).
See the difference?
>>Until proven otherwise, all possibilities are open. (Yes, including
>>the "Shinji is a clone" thing.) The Lance *could* be an Angel. That's
>>a given. The purpose of your proof is to show that it *could not* be,
>>hence limiting the possibilities. As is, the burden of proof is on
>>you. I merely stated that such a thing is possible.
If you honestly believe that, then to debate anything with you is
pointless, since nothing will ever be proven.
There comes a point when ambiguity, mangled semantics and
not-a-shred-of-proof theories cease being anywhere close to reasonable
and instead become simply ludicrous. Things on the level of "Shinji is a
clone," "the Lance could be an Angel" and "an unknown Angel that never
appears or is named in the series, nor has any bearing on anything in
the series" definitely fall into this category.
If that is the position that you are taking, then this debate is over.
>>Me in a lose-lose situation? Get real. First prove the validity of
>>your "Lance contains Adam's S^2" statement. *Then* ask.
I drop my "Lance contains Adam's S^2" statement from the argument.
Okay, I am now asking -- Which is it?
"And yes, either way you are in a lose-lose situation."
More information about the oldeva