[EVA] Adam-Lilith, quite a few spoliers in the long answer

Ebj ebj.nerv at flashnet.it
Sun Sep 2 18:32:42 EDT 2001


> The thing I do not like is the twisting of facts and mis-application of
Occam's
> razor to portray other possibilities (many of which can be eliminated by the
facts
> in the series) as more likely.

I should probably refrain from applying the razor, even if just because a)I'm
not familiar with it and b)I hate that kind of thing.

> The liner notes remain vague on whether Lilith is the 2nd Angel.  However, the
> sections where they state that Adam and Lilith are the same sources of life do
not
> use any of these qualifying phrases, and are quite clear.

Meaning to say, if we are to answer yes to the question "is Adam the 1st angel"
since it is canon info, we should also accept that Adam and Lilith are the same
source of life?

> > But, if you were to say that they are same as sources of life, it would not.
>
> I don't follow...

Perhaps it is a mistake on my part, but if we are to consider them as the same
SOL, shouldn't what has come from One of them also have come from the other?
Shouldn't therefore Lilim and angels come from both Adam and Lilith at the same
time?

> Regardless, if Rei was not created following Seele's plan, then she cannot be
> included in the official Angel numbering.

Agreed.

>  In contrast, Lilith was
> discovered/captured according to plan and at approximately the right time (ie:
in
> the correct order).  Further, given Adam's classification as the 1st Angel, it
is
> possible for Lilith to be the 2nd.

It may be so. If all that supports the "Lilith is not an angel at all" theory is
proven wrong, then I'd say she'd fit the place.

_______________________________________________________________
| IMMANO.ORG    \______________________________________________|
----------------|  <= => AV      @ # ? ! % & //     more...    |
|             E=|__desc__________________________title&whatnot_|
|             i |                                              |
|             ç |      @  + immano at immano.org                  |
|            * /          + immano.org at flashnet.it             |
\  @   §  ->  /        -------------------------------------   |
 \-----------/            : http://immano.port5.com            |




More information about the oldeva mailing list